On the afternoon of Feb. 17, 2026, a cacophony of screams, slurs, and bible verses were heard from a crowd outside of Gordinier Hall. At the center of it stood a small group of individuals led by a man holding a sign that read “OBEY JESUS OR HELLFIRE.” The affair ended with a Millersville student being escorted away in handcuffs.
Pastor Aden Rusfeldt is the founder of Key of David Christian Center, a non-denominational Christian church based in Philadelphia. However, he is no stranger to Millersville University or other public institutions; his inflammatory language and actions have been spotted on the campuses of West Chester University, Kutztown University, and University of Delaware.
Several members of Millersville’s student body deemed Rusfeldt’s actions not as “preaching”, but rather hate speech, harassment, or “rage-baiting.” One of his picket signs listed 18 groups of people that would burn in hell, among them included “f——,” “sluts,” and “t——-.”
Alyssa, a freshman, said Rusfeldt’s words made her “physically sick.” She shared, “As someone from the LGBTQ community, it hurts when they say slurs like that. I just heard them say that Muslims are dangerous and that Jews are dangerous, which is not true.” Rusfeldt allegedly told her she would burn in hell because she was not wearing a skirt.
About an hour after the crowd formed, friends Evan Zimmerman and Peter Coulbourne marched hand-in-hand to a Key of David member. The two began kissing out of protest, which was met by cheers of support by fellow Millersville students. Zimmerman believed the group was there for a reaction from the crowd as an excuse to incite violence. Coulbourne commented, “I think these people were here to spread hate. Spreading hate does nothing but reflect their own character.”
Pete Anders, University Police Chief, reported that a female student later incited a “minor disturbance” when she grabbed a microphone belonging to Rusfeldt’s wife, Mary. Anders stated, “Officers removed the student from the area for disorderly conduct as she pushed the woman who tried to take back the microphone. The student received a summary citation and was released shortly after from our police station.” Soon after, the crowd dispersed and the Key of David members left Millersville University.
The next day, a notice was published in Ville Daily referring students to a web page with information about freedom of speech versus hate speech. Mary Dolheimer, the Senior Director of Public Relations, explained that Millersville, as a member of Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education, is a public institution. As such, it is required to allow people to utilize their freedom of speech rights and express their opinions on campus. “It doesn’t necessarily mean that anyone particularly cared for what the reverend was saying,” said Dolheimer. “But he does have the right to express his opinion.”
Chief Anders echoed these sentiments, and shared that Rusfeldt has a history of suing colleges and municipalities where he was removed while engaging in free speech activities. “I will protect the Constitutional rights of others even when their speech is in deep conflict with my personal beliefs,” Anders said. “I also would not expose MU to financial risk by removing someone I know has protected speech.”
At the end of the day, Pastor Aden Rusfeldt has the right to speak on Millersville’s campus. But, what is he trying to say?
On Feb. 28, I had a phone call with Pastor Aden’s wife, Mary. She informed me of her background, saying she lived a very different, “fake Christian” life than the one she leads now. A Texas native, she met Aden at a Bible school in Houston where they shared testimonies. They have since been married for 23 years and have six children.
Mary is fulfilled by her role as a pastor’s wife, sharing, “I take this job very seriously whenever I say this. So, Titus 2:3-5. This is what me, as an older woman, (am) to be teaching the younger women in the church.” Mary is responsible for answering questions any woman at Key of David may bring, “I just kind of just take it on as a mom.”
A few days later, I spoke with Pastor Aden over the phone.
The David Christian Center was founded in September of 2016. Rusfeldt has reportedly preached on Millersville’s campus about once a year since its inception. However, universities were far from his launch pad; Pastor Aden began preaching at his local bus stop, as well as Mardi Gras at Galveston, Texas. He and his family soon began attending bigger events such as Pride parades and the Odunde Festival, while occasionally speaking at bars or Planned Parenthood locations.
However, Pastor Aden and his family now preach at public universities several times a month. “Colleges, I think, are the most conductive, because you can actually kind of have a debate, an argument, a back and forth,” explained Rusfeldt.
“But my intention is not always to just be argumentative,” he said. “What we found is that people with softer hearts are less argumentative. They’re a little more (curious), inquisitive, better dialogue…super hard-hearted people? They just want to literally mace you, punch you, slap you, stab you, get you falsely arrested.”
Pastor Aden identified himself as soft-hearted. However, he argued that his messages are not cruel or harmful, but true and necessary to point out. Referencing the idiom “a hit dog will holler”, he claimed, “If I say to a group of 10 women, like, ‘Shame on any of you that are sluts,’ and one of them goes, ‘Oh my God!’…then obviously the word hit her.” Rusfeldt said that words are not harsh to everybody.
He further argued that his methods are like a “loud warning”, which he classified as loving. However, Pastor Aden stated that neither love nor hate can be put in front of the other. “They’re absolutely equal…See, you guys think hatred is like this whole personal thing. It’s not.”
Chris Peter is a pastor with Reformed University Fellowship, a ministry that meets on Millersville’s campus. He deemed Key of David as a terrible witness for Jesus, and claimed that Pastor Aden was misinterpreting the Bible.
“I think that there is a way in which we are called to speak truth in love, and nothing about the way in which I’ve seen this ministry or church go about speaking to people is speaking the truth in love,” said Peter. “And so I think it’s really destructive to the Christian witness.”
Chris encouraged students to engage with the community of faith that is actively present on Millersville’s campus. He emphasized that Key of David changes locations, meaning they do not have to face the repercussions of their actions. He recommended finding a community where one can wrestle with tough questions and see what true Christianity looks like when lived out.
“Jesus says, ‘Come to me, all of you who are weary and heavy burdened, and I will give you rest’. And I think that is certainly what I’m wanting to do as a pastor: that students would come and find freedom, and that they would be finding joy in the midst of that,” Peter said.



